FIAON › Ratgeber › Ratgeber

Business credit card refused: what was actually checked

Von Johanna Brecht, Redakteurin für Verbraucherfinanzen · 9.9.2026 · 9 Min. Lesezeit

The refusal arrives by email, three sentences long, with no reasons given. "Following a review of your documents, we are unfortunately unable to approve your application." Turnover is fine, the account is in credit, the order book is healthy. Still: no.

Card companies do not explain their refusals, and they are not obliged to. What they check can still be reconstructed fairly closely – from the documents they ask for, and from the features that feed into a business credit report. In most cases it is not the business that fails. It is one of four things: a missing disclosure, a short account history, an entry against the owner personally – or the fact that too many applications went out in quick succession.

The galling part is that all four would have been visible before the application.

What sits behind the check

A business credit card is a loan. Between the day you fill up at the pump and the day the monthly statement is settled by direct debit, there can be up to six weeks in which somebody else is fronting the money. Whoever issues a card like that carries the default risk, and checks accordingly.

The company is not the only thing being checked, either. The smaller and the younger it is, the further the person behind it moves into view. With sole traders and freelancers, the firm's credit standing and the owner's are the same thing anyway. With a young GmbH that has no track record, the managing director's own report is usually pulled as well, because the company has nothing yet to show.

That explains something that puzzles a lot of owners: a business with clean figures is turned down over a private entry against its owner, years old and with nothing to do with the trading at all.

The four most common reasons

The annual accounts were never disclosed. Section 325 HGB (the German Commercial Code) allows a GmbH, a UG or an AG one year after the balance sheet date to put its accounts into the Unternehmensregister ("company register"); for a capital-market-oriented company the window is four months. Miss the date and you risk more than administrative fine proceedings under Section 335 HGB. The gap is publicly visible, and it leaves the credit agency with nothing for the balance sheet element, which carries ten per cent of the Bonitätsindex, Creditreform's business credit index. Absent figures rarely read as neutral.

The business account is too young. Under six months there is barely any account conduct worth evaluating. The underwriter looks at the size and the steadiness of turnover, at returned direct debits, and at whether an overdraft line sits permanently exhausted. An account running at its limit month after month is a worse signal than an account with no limit at all.

A negative entry against the company or the owner. This is the point where the most can be done, because not every report was lawful in the first place. Section 31(2) BDSG (the Federal Data Protection Act) permits an unpaid claim to be reported only where the sum is due, where the debtor had two reminders sent no less than four weeks apart, where the debtor was told in advance that a report was coming, and where the claim is not in dispute. Miss one of those and the entry can be attacked.

Too many enquiries in quick succession. The refusal itself is not stored. The enquiry is, and for twelve months. Try four providers inside a few weeks and you leave a pattern behind that the fifth one will see. A pure condition enquiry (Konditionsanfrage) does nothing to the assessment. You have to ask for it in plain terms, though.

The sequencing mistake

The most expensive error is not any single defect. It is the order. Plenty of businesses apply first and tidy up afterwards, which means they collect refusals, and every refusal narrows the check that follows.

The reverse works: request your own report, read the entries, catch up on a missing disclosure, and apply only after that. The first step costs nothing and takes a few days at most credit agencies.

Step by step before you apply

1. Request the business credit report. From the Creditreform branch that covers where the company is registered; alongside it CRIF, and, where owner data carries weight, SCHUFA.
2. Request your own copy of your data ("Datenkopie"). Under Article 15 GDPR, free of charge, with a deadline of one month. For sole traders and small companies this is the more important of the two data sets.
3. Hold every entry against Section 31(2) BDSG. Due, two reminders, four weeks apart, notice that a report was coming, not disputed – if one of those is missing, an objection belongs in the post.
4. Open the company register. Are the most recent annual accounts in there? If not, file them, late or not. That also brings any running fine proceedings to an end.
5. Read the business account the way an underwriter reads it. Returned direct debits in the past six months? An overdraft limit permanently at the ceiling? Both can be cleaned up inside a few weeks.
6. Ask for a condition enquiry instead of a credit enquiry. Expressly, in writing, before the check runs.
7. Only then apply – and, where it is possible, with a smaller opening limit that gets raised later. An approved small limit with a clean payment record opens more doors than a refused large one.

What is realistic if the answer stays no

If the refusal stands, there are intermediate steps that keep the day-to-day payments moving, even though none of them buys you a payment term.

A debit card on a credit-balance basis works everywhere a genuine credit line is not required, and it quietly builds the account history you will want later. A card against a security deposit locks away an amount which is then released as a limit. That costs liquidity, but it produces a real credit card number, which is what hotel and hire car deposits are looking for. Prepaid cards are the simplest solution and the dearest per euro spent.

What does not exist is a business credit card with a genuine limit and no credit check at all. Anyone advertising one means one of the three variants above.

What should be on the table before the first meeting

The paperwork differs from provider to provider, but the core of it repeats. Have this folder ready and you will not lose a fortnight to chasing documents – and chasing documents is the second most common reason an application quietly dies.

• Commercial register extract (Handelsregisterauszug), current, no older than three months.
• The most recent annual accounts, together with the management accounts for the current year. For sole traders and freelancers, the income surplus statement and the latest tax assessment.
• Statements from the business account, usually the last three to six months.
• Identification of the beneficial owners, plus the entry in the Transparenzregister (transparency register). Under the Money Laundering Act this is not a formality but a precondition.
• List of shareholders (Gesellschafterliste), where the company is a GmbH or a UG.
• Your own business and owner credit reports. Nobody asks for these, and they are the actual reason the list works: you know in advance what the underwriter is going to see.

That last point is the one carrying the whole sequence. Every other document is already in the building.

The first limit is rarely the last

Those who do get a card often get it with a limit below the one they applied for. It feels like half a refusal. It is the usual way in, and it is a far better starting point than a rejected application for the full sum.

Increases follow much the same pattern almost everywhere: six to twelve months of statements settled on time, a limit used regularly but not exhausted, and turnover that matches the business you described. Draw the limit down to the last euro every month and you signal tightness, not growth.

An increase is also usually handled as a contract amendment rather than a fresh application, which spares you another credit enquiry. Ask about that expressly, before somebody opens a new application on your behalf.

Who is liable in the end – the question too few people ask

Business cards come in two basic forms, and the difference almost never surfaces in the marketing material.

Under corporate liability, the company is the contracting party. The statement goes to the business, the debit comes off the business account, and the card never appears in the owner's private credit standing. This is the form people mean when they say business card, and the form the checking is done for.

Under personal liability, the cardholder is the contracting party. The company reimburses the outlay but owes the card company nothing. Cards like this are approved faster, because they hang on private credit standing. You pay for that speed: if a statement goes unpaid, the default is yours privately, and it may well land in your personal credit report, with everything that implies for your next private loan.

Ask, then, before you sign, which of the two you are being offered and who the contract names as cardholder. Where corporate liability is refused, the personally liable variant is a possible intermediate step – but it is a different decision, not a smaller version of the same one.

What FIAON takes on

With a power of attorney, FIAON collects both reports – the one on the company and the one on you personally – and works through them entry by entry: the source, the date it drops out of the file, and whether it was ever permitted to be reported. Corrections are drafted, posted and chased until an answer comes back. After that the card application is put together with the card partner: papers assembled, sequence kept, a condition enquiry asked for in place of a credit enquiry. Nothing goes out before you have confirmed it. Which card you are offered, and at what limit, is the card company's decision.

What does not work

Nobody can tell you whether your application will go through. Card companies check by their own rules. They do not publish them, and more than credit standing feeds in – the issuer's own risk appetite that month, for one, which has nothing to do with you.

Legitimate entries do not vanish before their deletion period runs out, and no measure on earth makes a young company older. Ignore both of those and apply anyway, and all you collect are enquiries that sit on file for twelve months.

The three sentences that matter

Business card applications rarely fail on turnover, and usually fail on a missing disclosure, a short account history, or an entry against the owner personally. All three are visible before you apply, provided you request your own report – it costs nothing, and it is the single step that saves the sequence. And if the answer stays no, a card against a security deposit keeps the payments moving until the history is there.